SUMMARY OF SEMINARS ABOUT CULTURE
I) Summary of definitions, talking about culture
In the first seminar we were talking about culture, especially about one very interesting research of netherlandish social scientist Geert Hofstede. He focused on different societies and cultures from the whole world and researched five important indexes – PDI (how is power distributed in the society, equally or unequally), IC (degree in which is man integrated into the group), MAS (distribution of roles in the society, gender, men’s and woman’s values,…), UAI (if the society needs to have certain and strict rules, needs to knot that things are in place, if it hates changes – „nanny states“ – the opposite is the tolerant country) and finally Long-Term Orientation, bus he hasn’t collected all the data yet.
In the second seminar we were talking about the definitons of culture, what does the word mean for us – which criteriums does a group have to fulfill to be described as a culture.. I agree with Hofstede that a group could be called culture if its members share the same institutions, values, behaviours, traditions… But I’d like to point out that we have to respect that its members are different personalities with their own view of thinking, different opinions.. Moreover, as a sociologist, I can say responsibly, that there is not any right or wrong definition of culture, race, nation or any other “group”.. I only think that a common view is that culture is a group of people who share the same values, have the same traditions. Considering this point of view we can talk about “west culture”, “European” culture, “Moslem” culture and everybody would know what we mean even though it is impossible to think that millions of Europeans share exactly the same values… Also for most of students culture means something what their members have in common. Then we discuss the topic of our videoconferences – if we think that we can define our group as „a culture“. For me, it is a very specific “culture” of students from many countries all over the world. I like this “multicultural” world and I appreciate that we can learn from each other about different traditions, cultures, habits.. That is what I like about it. I think we can’t say that we are a group with specific culture or we are a culture, but at least we can say that we are one “videoconference culture” from 10.00 to 11.30 p.m. every Wednesday... For me, the teachers are definitely members of the group and that is what I like about the lectures, there is nobody more than anybody else and we discuss every topic openly. It depends on the lecture and specific topic, sometimes I fell as part of a culture of Masaryk University, sometimes I don’t see any differences between our students and students on the other side of screen. But most of the students think that videoconferences are very interesting and we can learn a lot from each other but we can’t describe our group as a culture.
II) Questions for students
1) I’d like to know if you see our videoconference group and people involved in them as a culture. Are the teachers members of our group? Are there two different groups from two countries or is there anything what we share or what we have in common? Can we define us as “a culture”?
2) If you consider the definition that culture is a group of people from the same country/background who have a lot in common, who share the same institutions, traditions, values…Do you think you can specify something very typical for your culture (Chinese/Japanese/French)?
3) I’d like to discuss the thesis of controversial social scientist Samuel Huntington’s thesis. His “Clash of Civilizations” is a controversial theory that people's cultural and religious identities will be the primary source of conflict in the post-Cold War world and the conflict between civilization and different cultures is the very typical feature of our world. He divided world into the "major" civilizations (eight): Western civilization, The Orthodox, Latin America, The Muslim world, Hindu civilization, The Sinic civilizatio, Japan, The civilization of Sub-Saharan Africa. I’d like to ask you if you see our world and contemporary events as a clash between different cultures…
4) Talking about culture not as a description of a group, but in general – culture which includes going to the cinema, theatre, reading books, listening to music or playing any music instrument, what does it mean for you? Is culture important for you?
Kristyna